5 Common Pieces Of Crappy Financial Advice

Care to share?

crappy financial adviceEverybody gets bad money advice at some point…

Most of us don’t ask for it, but well-intentioned people offer it up anyways. Some of it is helpful. Maybe a wise parent or grandparent taught you to start investing for retirement from your first paycheck or keep an emergency fund. Much of the financial advice that has come my way however, has been less than useful.

I’ve had a lot of people offer me tips over the years, and as an adult, I’ve learned the hard way that a lot of the advice I’ve been given is crap.

Nobody gives out crappy financial advice on purpose. Usually the well-intentioned individual really believes that they are helping. Often their advice is rooted in some big mistake that they made in their life that they want to try and steer you away from.

Here are a few bits of crap advice that I have personally been given.

It’s important to build up your credit score

In my opinion, this is one of the dumbest things that you could tell a young person who is just getting started with money. But this advice is persistent. It’s something that I was told over and over when I was in my late teens. I’ve heard it offered to several others over the years. It is terrible advice.

Why this advice sucks:

  • The main reason to build your credit is to increase your eligibility to borrow money. Borrowing money is a dangerous habit for a young person to get into.
  • To build credit, you need to borrow money and pay it back. See above.
  • The banks want you to use credit to buy things. They want you to believe that the only way to obtain nice things to to finance them, and to finance them, you need good credit. This is false. The best way to purchase anything is with real money.
  • You only need a good credit score if you want to go into debt to purchase things.

Now, before you hit the comment section to tell me how wrong I am, let me say this – I know that there is value in good credit. I myself have an exceptional credit rating, and it helped me buy a house. I do not believe that young people should make this a focus. Too many young people get up to their eyeballs in debt before they even understand what they’re doing. I was one of them. 

If you’re really determined to build up your credit, there are a few clever and safe ways to do it such as a prepaid credit card.

Buy a new vehicle so you have a warranty

It has been suggested to me many times that buying a new car is a great investment because you get a warranty so you’ll never have to worry about it. I have several friends who have used this argument in defense of a new vehicle purchase.

Why this advice sucks

If you do your research and buy a vehicle with low-mileage at a good price, you will always be farther ahead financially than if you had financed a new car. By buying a three year old car you are saving half the cost of what you’d pay new, and that’s not including interest on the loan.

Financial decisions are always about managing risk. Plainly, there is almost zero chance that your used vehicle will have a breakdown that will exceed the amount you saved by not buying new. I drive a 26 year old car and it has never let me down.

You need to retire early

This is a really popular idea in the blogging/make money online/work from home circles right now. When I first started this site, I noticed that a lot of bloggers are calling themselves “FIRE” (financially independent, retire early) bloggers. Everybody wants to retire early. There are stories of people all over the internet retiring in their 40s, 30s and even 20s. Though this is a nice thought, it starts to fall apart when you look closely.

Why it sucks

The idea of retirement is predicated on the assumption that you don’t enjoy your work. When you don’t enjoy what you do, you need to work as hard as you can to retire from it.

To be clear, I’m not against retirement. It’s wise to invest in your future. That said, shouldn’t we be teaching the next generation to find fulfillment in their work, rather than trying to get out of their job as fast as possible?

For most of us, our day job is one of the main contributions we get to make to society. So rather than telling young people that they should try to retire at 30 and live on a beach or whatever, let’s teach them to seek out meaningful employment or start a business that empowers them to do what they really enjoy. when you love your work, the concept of retirement is much less enticing.

You should take out student loans to pay for school

Most of us know that furthering your education gives you a better return on your money than you’re likely to get elsewhere. Student loans can be a good thing when all other options have been exhausted and they’re coupled with a short-term plan for repayment. I took a small student loan when I went to college, and somehow managed to take eight years to pay it off.

Why this advice sucks

  • There’ s a good chance that you don’t need to fully fund your education with student loans. You can save beforehand, work part-time, forgo vehicle ownership, live on-campus or with family rather than renting and budget your money to stretch what you have.
  • It places a financial burden on you at the very beginning of your career, when you’re least equipped to handle it.
  • It’s often the easy way out when a little more planning and patience could get you to the same place but without debt (or with less debt).

Of course student loans are necessary for some and since education is such a good investment, I wouldn’t hesitate to take one if there were no other options. That’s the thing though, there are ways to get around it. I know many people who have managed to get through college/university without debt, and many others who are still paying off student loan debt years later. You get to choose which camp you want to be in.

You should buy because renting is just throwing money away

As a homeowner, this one really annoys me. I spent a decade and a half renting and thinking I was just throwing money down the drain…that would be a really, really big drain. Renting is not throwing money away. Paying to have a roof over your head is one of the most important ways you can spend your money. The truth is that home ownership in many markets is far more expensive than renting. 

Renting can be a great way to live. If you have a good landlord and are happy with your home and the cost, do you need to buy? No, you don’t. I own my home, and I’m glad that I do. But there’s this idea out there that ownership is the best choice for everybody, and it’s not.

Why this advice sucks

  • Paying to have a roof over your head is never throwing your money away.
  • The responsibility of paying for a major expense is on the owner. Sometimes these can run well into the tens of thousands of dollars (like this for example).
  • The money you save every month by not have to pay for building insurance, repairs, strata fees etc. can be invested for a better rate of return than you will get in many real estate markets.
  • It makes more sense to rent and have a healthy investment portfolio, than to be mortgage-poor and hope the value of your home rises.

What I have learned

Always take financial advice from those who you trust, understand your situation and obviously, are doing well in the area that they’re advising you. Often people give advice or tips based on their mistakes. This advice is often rooted in fear and should not be trusted. If you want to know if you should buy a home, try to find somebody who is qualified to talk on the matter. A local real estate investor, maybe your parents or a friend’s parents. Pick somebody who is wise with their money.

Question for you:

 What piece of bad financial advice have you received?

Care to share?

Mike Greig

17 thoughts on “5 Common Pieces Of Crappy Financial Advice”

  1. Yes!!! I have heard every single one of these so often, I believed almost all of them. I’m grateful that I snapped out of it before TOO much damage was done!

    • I just wish people would stop handing out advice that they are not qualified to give. If you’re not an economist, close friend or family who has a solid history of wise financial management, don’t offer advice to young people. It really is that simple.

  2. I think each piece of advice you listed has a time and place. It may be great advice at one point in your life but awful advice in another. With personal finance advice (well, really any advice) it’s important to evaluate the reasoning behind it and figure out if it’s worth following.

    • That’s true. I can only speak from my perspective but you’re correct, some of these things might make sense for some people in some situations. It’s important to know yourself, your means and your tendencies well enough to know what’s best for you. If you don’t, seek help from a trusted adviser.

      This article is intended to focus on advice that is given to young people. Perhaps I should put that in the title. Much of this stuff came at me in my early twenties when I was still figuring out what it meant to spend responsibly.

  3. Awesome! I agree with so much of this! Renting also allows you to invest in your mobility. You aren’t permanently tied down to a place and can pick up and move quickly if you need to. And I love to see people doing something that gives them fulfillment. I am a middle school teacher and basketball coach and I love it! I can’t see myself in a different career path. I think if people can find something they truly love, they will do it with more passion and contribute so much more to the world and people around them!

    Great insights and interesting perspectives! Thanks for sharing!

  4. The two points you critiqued which are the most controversial, in my opinion, are FIRE and home ownership. Really great points on both. I’m not exactly sure where I stand on FIRE, except that I’d like to have the freedom to go on a 2-3 month trip whenever I want, and then come back to work. So it seems like finding some sort of unconventional job or supplemental passive income stream is key. Regarding homes, the biggest two financial positives I see in owner-occupied real estate are (1) investment in the RE market with potential for equity via appreciation, and (2) equity built by monthly debt pay down. That said, of your home isn’t appreciating in value, you’ve lost one of those reasons, and you can easily save $100-$200 extra per month while renting to account for the principal you would have been paying down on your mortgage. Just invest those bucks in some market (heck use an REIT fund if you’re set on real estate) to make that cash work for you instead of collecting dust. Thanks again for a great post.

  5. Don’t throw out the concept of FIRE because you don’t think you’d want to retire early. The important part of that is the FI part. You won’t retire early unless you’re financially independent (or at least won’t be able to stay retired), but being financially independent doesn’t require you to retire early. There are lots of things beyond your control. Jobs get outsourced or made obsolete, recessions happen, major health crises arise. You may need to take an extended break to care for a sick loved one, or you might want to take a trip of a lifetime that you can’t do while fully employed. Plus, there are a lot of fulfilling things to do that won’t provide enough income to maintain your lifestyle. Unless you’re striving for financial independence so that you *could* retire early (which most FIRE proponents note means you spend your time doing what you want to do, which may or may not be the same thing you are already doing), you’re seriously limiting your options if something outside your control changes for the worse.

    • Thank you for the well thought out comment DiC.

      I don’t mean to discredit the idea entirely; in fact I agree completely that financial independence is a worthy pursuit for everybody. My concern is that I don’t see much material around focusing on why a person might want to retire early. What that actually means, what you life might look like post-retirement, and how to put your skills and passions to work afterwards so that you’re still a benefit to your community and society.

      I have see a great many people retire to the golf/hawaii/RV stereotypical 65+ lifestyle only to return to the workforce after a couple of years because they’re bored. For most of us, our work is what gives us purpose, it’s what drives us to become better and gives us a goal to work towards.

  6. Good stuff!

    The credit score talk annoys me to no end too.

    Also on the retirement discussion, it’s so true. We should all be growing our net worth to a place we don’t need an income, but without the goal of doing nothing anymore!

    • Thanks RHHM! I like the idea of retirement, but I feel like the personal finance blogging community has really focused on the ‘retire early’ part and not spent much time on the ‘why’ or the ‘what next’.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.